| Old Altamont Reservoir | Effingham, IL | 1.9 miles | SE |
| Shoemakers Pond | Effingham, IL | 3.9 miles | SE |
| Altamont Reservoir | Effingham, IL | 4.1 miles | SE |
| Lake Nellie | Fayette, IL | 6.1 miles | SW |
| Lake Nellie | Fayette, IL | 6.3 miles | SW |
| Bails Timberline Lake | Fayette, IL | 7.1 miles | SW |
| Lake Timberland | Fayette, IL | 7.1 miles | SW |
| Lake Sara | Effingham, IL | 7.2 miles | NE |
| Saint Elmo Old City Reservoir | Fayette, IL | 7.5 miles | SW |
| Roberts Lake | Effingham, IL | 8.4 miles | SW |
| Little Wabash River Reservoir | Effingham, IL | 8.4 miles | NE |
| Central Illinois Public Service Reservoir | Effingham, IL | 8.8 miles | NE |
| Cips Lake | Effingham, IL | 8.9 miles | NE |
| Lake Pauline | Effingham, IL | 10.3 miles | NE |
| Oliver Reece Pond | Fayette, IL | 13.3 miles | SW |
| Lake Walter Scott | Effingham, IL | 14.7 miles | SE |
| McArthur Lake | Clay, IL | 14.7 miles | SE |
| Patterson Lake | Clay, IL | 15.1 miles | SE |
| Hickory Ridge Pond | Shelby, IL | 17 miles | NE |
| Saint Peter Sportsman Lake | Fayette, IL | 17.9 miles | SW |
| Gatch Lake | Fayette, IL | 17.9 miles | SW |
| Ging Lake | Clay, IL | 18.2 miles | SE |
| Stanbery Lake | Fayette, IL | 18.5 miles | SW |
| Bass Lake | Shelby, IL | 19.2 miles | NE |
| Rocky Ford Sportsman Club South Lake | Montgomery, IL | 20 miles | SE |
| Vandalia Municipal Reservoir | Fayette, IL | 20.3 miles | SW |
| Langley Pond | Shelby, IL | 20.4 miles | NW |
| Ramsey Lake | Fayette, IL | 21.5 miles | NW |
| Whitfield Lake | Macoupin, IL | 22 miles | NW |
| Lake Mattoon | Shelby, IL | 22.3 miles | NE |
| Lake Matton | Coles, IL | 22.3 miles | NE |
| Lake Shelbyville | Shelby, IL | 22.5 miles | NW |
| Kinmundy Lake | Marion, IL | 23 miles | SW |
| Vandalia Lake | Fayette, IL | 23.2 miles | SW |
| Boy Scout Lake | Shelby, IL | 23.3 miles | NW |
| Lake Louise | Shelby, IL | 23.5 miles | NE |
| Suttons Pond | Fayette, IL | 23.9 miles | SW |
| Pana Lake | Shelby, IL | 24.2 miles | NW |
| Patoka Club Lake | Marion, IL | 24.7 miles | SW |
| Boston Lake | Marion, IL | 24.7 miles | SW |
| Montrose City Lake | Cumberland, IL | 24.8 miles | NE |
| Woodbury Lake | Cumberland, IL | 24.8 miles | NE |
| Illinois No Name Number 2040 Reservoir | Fayette, IL | 25 miles | SW |
| Burgett Lake | Jasper, IL | 25.2 miles | SE |
| Lake Pana | Christian, IL | 25.2 miles | NW |
| Forbes Lake | Marion, IL | 25.6 miles | SE |
| Forbes Lake | Marion, IL | 25.8 miles | SW |
| Marlow Pond | Marion, IL | 26.4 miles | SW |
| Paragon Lake | Christian, IL | 27 miles | NW |
| Fillmore Lake | Montgomery, IL | 27.2 miles | NW |
|